A neighborhood staple since the late ’90s, Paulie’s combines a mom-and-pop attitude with seriously good Italian food. Despite the love shown to its housemade pastas, the hoagies and panini are not to be overlooked. Go for classic Italians, shrimp BLTs, and crispy panini stuffed with the likes of salami, mozzarella, and spinach. And for your sweet tooth: decorated shortbread cookies.